A ruling by the High Court of Justice means that The Pirate Bay could soon be blocked by internet providers across the U.K.
The noose appears to be tightening on the major players in the piracy game. In the latest development, a ruling in a case brought by major record labels including Sony, EMI and Warner set the stage for a legally-mandated block of The Pirate Bay in the United Kingdom. Under the terms of Section 97A of the Copyright, Designs, and Patent Act, a court can compel an ISP to block a website “if it can be proven that it had knowledge that its services were being used to infringe copyright.” That law was used late last year to impose a block of Newzbin2 and now it’s TPB’s turn on the block.
A ruling issued by Justice Arnold of the High Court recognized the similarities between the two sites but said case against The Pirate Bay is even stronger. He also pointed out that The Pirate Bay is quite capable of removing infringing material, as it does with torrents that are mislabeled, child pornography, malware or spam, but “as a matter of policy” chooses not to do so.
“Indeed, according to a statement on the website, the reason for its recent adoption of Magnet links as the default option is that ‘it’s not as easy to block as .torrent files’. This confirms the operators’ determination to do whatever they can to provide users with unrestricted access to torrent files and thereby enable the users to continue to infringe,” he ruled. “In my judgment, the operators of TPB do authorize its users’ infringing acts of copying and communication to the public. They go far beyond merely enabling or assisting. On any view, they ‘sanction, approve and countenance’ the infringements of copyright committed by its users. But in my view they also purport to grant users the right to do the acts complained of.”
“I consider the present case to be indistinguishable from 20C Fox v Newzbin in this respect,” he added. “If anything, it is a stronger case.”
The Pirate Bay remains accessible in the U.K. for now but if things continue in this direction, a nationwide ISP block could be in place in “a matter of months.”
Source: TorrentFreak
Published: Feb 20, 2012 10:52 pm